ggFTW

ggFTW (http://ggftw.com/forum/)
-   Contests & Events (http://ggftw.com/forum/contests-events/)
-   -   Grand Signature Tournament Round One [1] Voting (http://ggftw.com/forum/contests-events/67576-grand-signature-tournament-round-one-1-voting.html)

Esper 01-01-2010 11:41 AM

Grand Signature Tournament Round One [1] Voting
 

Voting System:
The poll consists of every participant (except for those disqualified). You may choose up to four [4] choices on the poll judging on each battle and the signature that attracts you most. It's recommend you pick one winner for each battle to keep things even.

Poll Votes:
Each point on the poll is equivalent to five [5] points. For example, 40 votes is 200 points.

Manual Post Votes:
Each manual text vote (which is posting a reply) counts as ten [10] points. For example, 40 votes is 400 points.
How to manual text vote: Reply to this thread choosing the battles you want to comment on with a legitimate reason or two. Illegitimate reasons will be ignored.
Extra Prize: If the tournament finals winner exceeds 1500 points, he/she will receive an extra 100 reputation points.
___________________________________________
BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai
Theme: Must demonstrate 'Nature'
Style: Soft/Dreamy

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y29...t/nature01.png http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y29...t/nature02.png
___________________________________________
Psfrk vs KoueNeeSama
Theme: Must use the color 'Red'
Style: Glossy

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y29...ment/red02.png http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y29...ment/red01.png
___________________________________________
LittleWing vs Sidero
Theme: Must use the color 'Green'
Style: Grunge

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y29...nt/green02.jpg
LittleWing is disqualified for failing to submit an entry. Sidero automatically goes through to 2nd Round.
___________________________________________
Glarbage vs Yuer
Theme: Must demonstrate 'Technology'
Style: Modern

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y29...chnology01.png http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y29...chnology02.jpg
___________________________________________
k0n vs xKakashi
Theme: Must demonstrate characters from any 'Anime'
Style: N/A

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y29...nt/anime01.png
XKakashi is disqualified for failing to submit an entry. k0n automatically goes through to 2nd Round.
___________________________________________
ShoutenM vs WhatThePhuc
Theme: Must use the color 'Orange'
Style: Fairy Dust/Fantasy

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y29...t/orange02.png
ShoutenM is disqualified for failing to submit an entry. WhatThePhuc automatically goes through to 2nd Round.
___________________________________________
Shnao vs menkthegreat
Theme: Must demonstrate 'Nature'
Style: Soft/Dreamy

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y29...t/nature03.png
menkthegreat is disqualified for failing to submit an entry. Shnao automatically goes through to 2nd Round.
___________________________________________
Noperative vs Luciane
Theme: Must demonstrate 'Space'
Style: Fractal Art

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y29...nt/space01.png http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y29...nt/space02.png



Poll closes in three [3] days.

Esper 01-01-2010 11:42 AM

Sorry for the confusion everyone. Please follow the Voting System and vote for the four [4] people in each category.

Thank you
__________________________________________________
Post Voting:
Compiled post votings to make it easier to tally up points.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shnao
BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai
- Shiny and nostalgic for the soft vibe. Pictures of seasons for nature.

Pshfrk vs KoueNeeSama
- Pointing out the red lips for the theme. The colors do shine in the darkness so that goes for the style. :o

Glarbage vs Yuer
- Cute. :3 Cats and computers are so common nowadays, for me at least. `-`

Noperative vs Luciane
- Although both sigs didn't really do so well with fractal art, my vote goes to Noperative for the mysterious outer space feel to it. lol @ the austronaut though

Quote:

Originally Posted by flaris
Kudaranai
Pshfrk
Glarbage
Noperative

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kenjii
Pshfrk gets my vote. Good effects, composition, and text. Just needs more lighting.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sidero
votes on bold.

BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai

i love the nature exposed on seasons photos.

Psfrk vs KoueNeeSama

theme was "highlighted" and i love the contrast.

Glarbage vs Yuer

i don't expect that. creative and cute.

Noperative vs Luciane

although i didn't like much, my vote is the first. it looks like a black hole or a supernova.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chesters
BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai
I find BriGuy92's to be more soft and dreamy, andThe collage of colors really makes it dreamlike. Kuda's is more sharp and picture-frameish, in my opinion.

Psfrk vs KoueNeeSama
KoueNee's signature really highlights the red and the literal and stylistic gloss. Psfrk's featured more red but I did not find the picture to be of a glossy-definition.

Glarbage vs Yuer
Glarbage's entire signature embodies the style, while Yuer's mainly just bases it on the computer in the pictures. The exterior of it seems to take away from being modern, in my opinion.

Noperative vs Luciane
I enjoy Noperative's more, in that it portrays more of the elements of space. Luciane had a good attempt at fractal art, but Noperative's has a more complete look.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Glarbage (Post 1111838)
My votes go to:

Kudaranai: Interesting concept, the signature gives a sense of realism while still maintaining the appearance of being... what's the word I'm looking for... cartooned? I dunno. I like it.

Pshfrk: While the color choices need some work, it comes together very well as a signature. Excellent depth, and the relation to the theme is interesting.

Glarbage: One of these looks like a signature, one of these looks like a page from a family photo album. Just saying.

Noperative: I like the concept, even if the depth is a bit confusing. :x

Quote:

Originally Posted by Yuer (Post 1111862)
BriGuy92
Kudaranai demonstrated Nature by presenting all the four seasons in high skills while BriGuy92 merely uses tree to represent nature. BriGuy92 wins my vote as it appears more soft/dreamy compared to Kudaranai's sharpness and brightness. I love the slogan on Kudaranai's signature and his/her high skill, but primarily on the style, I prefer BriGuy92's softness. The colors gold, blue, green, and white also bring out the seasons in a more soft way.

Psfrk
Creative and surprising. The focus of red is accentuated extremely well with the red lips. KoueNeeSama is also creative in able to pick out a scene with both characters in red (well, one is dark red I guess), but it doesn't demonstrate glossy as well as Psfrk.

Yuer
While Glarbage does have a point that my signature seems like a picture from photo album (and it is true that those 2 pictures did come from my cat's album LOL. I thought the pictures had to be original so yeah...), I still vote for my own because technology is often represented with high tech robot, wires, green, digital numbers and such, so I thought it will be more creative to give technology a soft side and connect technology with reality. Signature will be more meaningful when it carries a message. So I vote for my own. Though, I do have to say that Glarbage's skill is way way way above mine >_>

Noperative
It is rather hard to pick a winner from this battle as both demonstrated space really well. I vote for Noperative as his/her space brings more confusion (just like the real space is) and thus gives more sense of mystery.

Quote:

Originally Posted by prison (Post 1112174)
BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai
Psfrk vs KoueNeeSama
Glarbage vs Yuer
Noperative vs Luciane
^ those 2 were really damn good :O
votes in bold/underline

Quote:

Originally Posted by xKakashi (Post 1112193)
BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai
Kuda demonstrates a higher level of skill in her signature and also CLEARLY displays all 4 seasons which.. is pretty self explanitory in how they represent nature. Bri's siggy is kinda vague and I dont really get it except for the trees. Kuda gets my vote

Pshfrk vs KoueNeeSama
Psh just has an all around better siggie tbh >< it isnt just a screencap with a couple brushings and text, there is actual blending and stuff going on. The red lips are also an awesome focal~

Glarbage vs Yuer
Glarbage's siggie looks more hidef and reminds me of "technology" more then lolcatz. Idk, I find cats annoying at this point v.v

Noperative vs Luciane
Both sigs are a bit confusing, but I understand cause it had a difficult style to work with. I overall like Noperative's because.. I like the earth? Idk, it just appeals to my eyes more rather then a confusing sun and stars @w@~

Quote:

Originally Posted by Noperative (Post 1112219)
BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai
Kuda's seem more clean and appealing while BriGuy is bordering on gaudy. In terms of a sig I'm willing to use, I'd go with Kuda's.

Psfrk vs KoueNeeSama
Similar arguement. Pshfrk's obviously shows more polish and effort, while KoueNeeSama's seems fit for something other than a sig.

Glarbage vs Yuer
I can't say I know what 'modern' style would be for a sig, but Glarbage does seem to have put more work in his.

Noperative vs Luciane
Fractal art is really hard you know :u I'm lucky Luciane didn't know what to do either or else I'd have died this round.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pshfrk (Post 1112250)
- - - - Votes in bold

BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai
I loved the composition, the colors, and typo. Pure "Armonia"

Pshfrk vs KoueNeeSama
I liked the idea of KoueNeeSama but, needs some work on colors and typo.

Glarbage vs Yuer
I loved the colors of the Yuer one... But as technology theme i think that the Glarbage one reflects more of it....(The cat is so cute ;_; )

Noperative vs Luciane
Luciane's one looks a little bit empty.

//Pshfrk

Quote:

Originally Posted by SOC (Post 1113545)
BriGuy92 vs. Kudaranai
I like Bri's a whole lot, heck, I'd use that as my sig. His soft colors give me a picture perfect idea of what nature is, at any given moment. I really like Kudaranai's too, but Bri's use of soft colors really appeal to me. Plus I'm lovin' those two white streaks in the sky.

Psfrk vs. KoueNeeSama

Honestly, I like the simple theme of Kou's more. When I think red, the theme of love comes to mind, and I love the way her text looks.

Glarbage vs. Yuer

Now this one was tough. I voted Yuer's mostly because I like how they made technology relate to today's standards. I like the thought of at any given moment today, there could be a cat napping on my laptop. :3

Noperative vs. Luciane

Nop's use of many colors in a sort of "spin" way caught my eye quickly. I'm just diggin' the overall feeling portrayed in that signature.


KouNeeSama 01-01-2010 01:29 PM

err, i think you switched mine with Psfrk's

Esper 01-01-2010 01:36 PM

What do you mean by switched. :x

Edit: Glarbaged fixed it for me. Thanks.

Harlequin 01-01-2010 01:37 PM

Images and poll fixed at Light's request.

Harlequin 01-01-2010 01:40 PM

My votes go to:

Kudaranai: Interesting concept, the signature gives a sense of realism while still maintaining the appearance of being... what's the word I'm looking for... cartooned? I dunno. I like it.

Pshfrk: While the color choices need some work, it comes together very well as a signature. Excellent depth, and the relation to the theme is interesting.

Glarbage: One of these looks like a signature, one of these looks like a page from a photo album. Just saying.

Noperative: I like the concept, even if the depth is a bit confusing. :x

Yuer 01-01-2010 02:23 PM

BriGuy92
Kudaranai demonstrated Nature by presenting all the four seasons in high skills while BriGuy92 merely uses tree to represent nature. BriGuy92 wins my vote as it appears more soft/dreamy compared to Kudaranai's sharpness and brightness. I love the slogan on Kudaranai's signature and his/her high skill, but primarily on the style, I prefer BriGuy92's softness. The colors gold, blue, green, and white also bring out the seasons in a more soft way.

Psfrk
Creative and surprising. The focus of red is accentuated extremely well with the red lips. KoueNeeSama is also creative in able to pick out a scene with both characters in red (well, one is dark red I guess), but it doesn't demonstrate glossy as well as Psfrk.

Yuer
While Glarbage does have a point that my signature seems like a picture from photo album (and it is true that those 2 pictures did come from my cat's album LOL. I thought the pictures had to be original so yeah...), I still vote for my own because technology is often represented with high tech robot, wires, green, digital numbers and such, so I thought it will be more creative to give technology a soft side and connect technology with reality. Signature will be more meaningful when it carries a message. So I vote for my own. Though, I do have to say that Glarbage's skill is way way way above mine >_>

Noperative
It is rather hard to pick a winner from this battle as both demonstrated space really well. I vote for Noperative as his/her space brings more confusion (just like the real space is) and thus gives more sense of mystery.

Moonflow 01-01-2010 04:02 PM

Sorry I missed this, busy as hell over christmas period.
I didn't even notice the PM untill yesterday >.>

Oh well goodluck to those who got one in on time~

Kenjii 01-01-2010 08:22 PM

EDIT: Nevermind. I see that the signatures were switched. Getting me messed up, cause I remember voting for KouNeeSama.

prison 01-01-2010 09:19 PM

BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai
Psfrk vs KoueNeeSama
Glarbage vs Yuer
Noperative vs Luciane
^ those 2 were really damn good :O
votes in bold/underline

Shnao 01-01-2010 09:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by prison (Post 1112174)
briguy92 vs kudaranai
psfrk vs koueneesama
glarbage vs yuer
noperative vs luciane
^ those 2 were really damn good :o
votes in bold/underline

Quote:

manual post votes:
Each manual text vote (which is posting a reply) counts as ten [10] points. For example, 40 votes is 400 points.
How to manual text vote: Reply to this thread choosing the battles you want to comment on with a legitimate reason or two. Illegitimate reasons will be ignored.
:( .

Kebin 01-01-2010 09:42 PM

BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai
Kuda demonstrates a higher level of skill in her signature and also CLEARLY displays all 4 seasons which.. is pretty self explanitory in how they represent nature. Bri's siggy is kinda vague and I dont really get it except for the trees. Kuda gets my vote

Pshfrk vs KoueNeeSama
Psh just has an all around better siggie tbh >< it isnt just a screencap with a couple brushings and text, there is actual blending and stuff going on. The red lips are also an awesome focal~

Glarbage vs Yuer
Glarbage's siggie looks more hidef and reminds me of "technology" more then lolcatz. Idk, I find cats annoying at this point v.v

Noperative vs Luciane
Both sigs are a bit confusing, but I understand cause it had a difficult style to work with. I overall like Noperative's because.. I like the earth? Idk, it just appeals to my eyes more rather then a confusing sun and stars @w@~

Noperative 01-01-2010 10:09 PM

BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai
Kuda's seem more clean and appealing while BriGuy is bordering on gaudy. In terms of a sig I'm willing to use, I'd go with Kuda's.

Psfrk vs KoueNeeSama
Similar arguement. Pshfrk's obviously shows more polish and effort, while KoueNeeSama's seems fit for something other than a sig.

Glarbage vs Yuer
I can't say I know what 'modern' style would be for a sig, but Glarbage does seem to have put more work in his.

Noperative vs Luciane
Fractal art is really hard you know :u I'm lucky Luciane didn't know what to do either or else I'd have died this round.



Lol Kakashi didn't make a sig, didn't you say it only took about 3 hours? And what's with k0n's and kaka's theme? It makes me feel bad about mine.

Kebin 01-01-2010 10:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Noperative (Post 1112219)
BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai
Kuda's seem more clean and appealing while BriGuy is bordering on gaudy. In terms of a sig I'm willing to use, I'd go with Kuda's.

Psfrk vs KoueNeeSama
Similar arguement. Pshfrk's obviously shows more polish and effort, while KoueNeeSama's seems fit for something other than a sig.

Glarbage vs Yuer
I can't say I know what 'modern' style would be for a sig, but Glarbage does seem to have put more work in his.

Noperative vs Luciane
Fractal art is really hard you know :u I'm lucky Luciane didn't know what to do either or else I'd have died this round.



Lol Kakashi didn't make a sig, didn't you say it only took about 3 hours? And what's with k0n's and kaka's theme? It makes me feel bad about mine.

@w@ I've been helping with another forum and game so this completely slipped my mind :py56: Im not gonna lie I even read the PM right when Mirae sent it xD

Pshfrk 01-01-2010 10:50 PM

- - - - Votes in bold

BriGuy92 vs Kudaranai
I loved the composition, the colors, and typo. Pure "Armonia"

Pshfrk vs KoueNeeSama
I liked the idea of KoueNeeSama but, needs some work on colors and typo.

Glarbage vs Yuer
I loved the colors of the Yuer one... But as technology theme i think that the Glarbage one reflects more of it....(The cat is so cute ;_; )

Noperative vs Luciane
Luciane's one looks a little bit empty.

//Pshfrk

k0n 01-02-2010 01:08 AM

Wasn't KoueNeeSama's and Pshfrk's signatures the other way around? O.o

"Extra Prize: If the tournament finals winner exceeds 1500 points, he/she will receive an extra 100 reputation points."

Also, what about those that didn't have a competition to get points? This happened last time too ;_;

ChocoKeiko 01-02-2010 05:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by k0n (Post 1112312)
Wasn't KoueNeeSama's and Pshfrk's signatures the other way around? O.o

The previous pool made me think that too :3

Shnao 01-02-2010 11:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by k0n (Post 1112312)
Wasn't KoueNeeSama's and Pshfrk's signatures the other way around? O.o

"Extra Prize: If the tournament finals winner exceeds 1500 points, he/she will receive an extra 100 reputation points."

Also, what about those that didn't have a competition to get points? This happened last time too ;_;

No, it was the wrong way to begin with, now it's been switched to the proper respective order. I know this because I've seen plenty of Pshfrk's sigs to tell which one is his.

prison 01-02-2010 03:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by prison View Post
briguy92 vs kudaranai
psfrk vs koueneesama
glarbage vs yuer
noperative vs luciane
^ those 2 were really damn good
votes in bold/underline
Quote:

manual post votes:
Each manual text vote (which is posting a reply) counts as ten [10] points. For example, 40 votes is 400 points.
How to manual text vote: Reply to this thread choosing the battles you want to comment on with a legitimate reason or two. Illegitimate reasons will be ignored.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shnao (Post 1112192)
:( .


But i don't have any other reason then ijust like them <_<

Esper 01-02-2010 07:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by k0n (Post 1112312)
"Extra Prize: If the tournament finals winner exceeds 1500 points, he/she will receive an extra 100 reputation points."

Also, what about those that didn't have a competition to get points? This happened last time too ;_;

Sorry for the late reply.

All those that automatically move onto the round will be given points. The value will be determined when the poll closes.
It wouldn't be fair to let you have 0 points while others have over 500 points [just random numbers].


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 10:40 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.