#1 gets my vote because the overall performance with the scanlines are done pretty well. And the text fits with the siggy as well.
The colors are a bit dull, but there are some dark & light contrast in it..so that makes up for it. ;P
I'd like number 1, but overall it didn't complete the task of the SoTW to me at least. It's too dull and monotoned in colors. Except for a hint of that little swoosh near the text :/
So my vote goes to 4, although the render is of poor quality, or the designer just meant to make it look like that, and the text is too plain, but I think it's the one that did the "fruityness" I'm looking for in this SoTW.
I sadly dont know anything about sig making so i cant judge from a critics point of view.
I just voted for which one looked the nicest to me, which was number 1.
They are all great tho and way better than anything i can do.