i voted for #2. i like the composition, but i do think that the black was over-used. it looks like the glow is supposed to project outward, but i get the impression that they brushed the black inwards and it creates the opposite intended effect.
I love the design of it [hearts and squares have a really nice color / texture] plus the font fits well with the whole sig. Plus that render looks smexy
__________________
『the enigma』
―
she runs because
that's the only thing
she can do.