There's no opinions in that thread, of what opinion there is, it's regarding whether or not to rip off /v/'s guide or format it by genre. Personal recommendations, I'll give you that much because I did not clarify. By personal, I meant personal and fit to the requester. Guides and lists are not fit to a single person, they are fit to a general. While it gets somewhere, it doesn't get there.
If you want to lower the amount of whatever activity this forum even has, by all means, more power to you. Nice to now that we have a helpful gaming community here that provides productive answers.