well the only shoujo manga i read is beauty pop and it's not magical at all. it's about a high school beautician's club. but the manga ka of beauty pop, Kiyoko Arai has another series called Ask Dr. Rin! That's magical. It's feng shui based fortune teller magical girl-ish type of plot going on. Because I liked Beauty Pop I checked out this other manga of her cos it was really popular and even has a anime series. I even downloaded the anime...
but i hated it.
but that's only cos i dislike magic. most of the things i like are mostly realistic. and if they aren't realistic they have a sci fi elemnt to them only. but since you like magic and because Ask Dr Rin! Is so much more popular than Beauty Pop I think you should give it a shot.
yes i'm a sexy free and single ಠ_ಠ